Here's the most recent and authoritative update (as of December 2025) on the judicial positions and verdicts concerning reduction of the commuted pension recovery period from 15 years to 10 years 8 months or any shorter period (e.g., 12 or about 10⅔ years):
📌 1. Supreme Court – Pending Challenge
The Supreme Court of India has recently issued notice on a Special Leave Petition (SLP) against a High Court judgment that upheld the 15-year restoration period for commuted pension under Rule 18 of the Andhra Pradesh Civil Pensions (Commutation) Rules, 1944. This case involves petitioners challenging the validity of a 15-year period as arbitrary and unjust. �
Verdictum
This is not a final verdict yet — but it is the leading ongoing national apex court challenge.
📌 2. High Courts on the Issue
🏛 Allahabad High Court – 2025
The Allahabad High Court (January 2025) upheld the 15-year recovery period for commuted pension in a writ petition (Ashok Kumar Agarwal & Ors. v. UOI & Another).
It ruled that retired employees who had voluntarily accepted the commutation scheme cannot later challenge the 15-year restoration period. The court reasoned it was a contractual acceptance, and that the argument for shorter periods (like 10 years) did not succeed. �
Lawyer News
🏛 Andhra Pradesh High Court – April 2025
The Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissed challenges to Rule 18 of the Civil Pensions Rules that prescribe restoration of commuted pension after 15 years.
The court emphasized that since employees availed benefits under the scheme, they cannot now challenge the restoration timeline. �
24Law
🏛 Telangana High Court – July 2025
The Telangana High Court also upheld the 15-year period, rejecting petitions that sought full pension restoration earlier. �
The Times of India
📌 3. Other Judicial Developments
⚖️ Punjab & Haryana High Court / Supreme Court Interaction
In a separate context, the Punjab & Haryana High Court (in late 2024) had allowed recovery up to 15 years but discussed rationalising this period based on when the commuted amount truly gets recovered (roughly around 11½ to 12 years in many cases). The Supreme Court has since asked Punjab to clarify when it will set up an expert committee to examine this issue — but no final verdict reducing the period has been given yet. �
The Times of India
⚖️ Allahabad HC (Individual Case – Bank Pension)
An Allahabad HC interim order (September 2024) stayed further recovery of commuted pension beyond 10 years 8 months in an individual bank pension case where the bank had already recovered the commutation amount by that period. This was a case-specific interim order (not a broad binding verdict altering national policy). �
NewsDrum
📌 4. Current Legal Position (Summary)
Verdict on Recovery Period
Court / Authority
Supreme Court (ongoing SLP)
Notice issued → challenge to 15yr rule under consideration (no final verdict yet) �
Verdictum
Allahabad HC (Jan 2025)
Upholds 15-yr period; rejects challenge to reduce recovery period �
Lawyer News
Andhra Pradesh HC (Apr 2025)
Upholds 15-yr period �
24Law
Telangana HC (Jul 2025)
Upholds 15-yr period �
The Times of India
Punjab & Haryana HC / SC
SC asking for committee timeline; no national reduction yet �
The Times of India
Allahabad HC (Sep 2024, interim)
Stay on further recovery beyond ~10y8m in that case only �
NewsDrum
🧾 Key Legal Takeaways
No binding Supreme Court verdict as yet reducing the recovery period from 15 years to 10 years 8 months or any other shorter timeframe for all pensioners. The matter is pending before the Supreme Court. �
Verdictum
High Courts continue to uphold the 15-year period where the commutation scheme was voluntarily accepted. �
Lawyer News +1
Individual interim orders (such as the one staying recovery beyond 10 years 8 months) exist but are case-specific and do not yet represent a binding change in law applicable to all. �
1 comment:
Retirees are spending a lot of time for reduction in restoration time of commutation of a portion of pension amount not for increase of pension periodically as every one is getting more and more wage/pension during the last three decades. There is not even a coordination of retirees of various units in financial sector but only one up man ship even among in one corporation/company. There is unity among them for being ungrateful to a PM who gifted pension to all formal workers and economic reforms to sustain a pension system and 3% increase PA in real wages for the last 3 decades to all members of working class whether formal or not. Rather they abused him and want to bring back dynastic, corrupt, casteist and regional political parties both in Centre and States ignoring stagnant wages without pension for 44 years except SBI since the liberation of India from British. So Karma punished one and all. Judiciary also join in punishing them by outright dismissal of their demands or prolong the legal process till their death. One doesn't know when working class will aware of their own mistakes unite for just rights and not yield to anyone of corrupt political parties and their henchmen. 80% families who suffered during 50 years of regime of the dynasty already died whether they fought it or not.
Post a Comment