Beloved Colleagues,
Earlier reports revealed praising the united move of all of our
Sr.Counsels who were present in the court hall to present our case under
common agreed upon agenda. When hearing commenced, Sri. Nidesh Gupta
had initiated his arguments with relevant details. Other three
Sr.Counsels also have unfurled their arguments based on factual
documents . It was then reported in a particular write-up that Hon'ble
Justice Khanna intervened several times not approving of our
submissions. It was even guessed that he might have had some inferences
The author of the report admitted earlier that all the four Sr.Counsels
had placed their arguments eloquently and the judge too heard them
keenly. There were no adverse remarks then about the part played by Sri.
Nidesh Gupta in the earlier report of the author of the present report.
Now he comes out with some explanations to please his followers that
every thing went wrong because of the initiation of the arguments of
Sri. Nidesh Gupta much against the normal procedure. At a time when the
author's advocate, being the senior-most, was expected to begin his
arguments, Sri. Nidesh Gupta stepped ( jumped )into the scene
voluntarily. These explanations are coming out since the verdict came in
favour of LIC. Had it been in our favour, the observations could have
been a different one. Is it because of belated wisdom ? We never
expected such unpalatable remarks from a seasoned gentleman about an
eminent Sr.Counsel who appears for a different group of clients. Quite
against his own earlier predictions about the mood of the judge based on
supposed inferences, now seeking a scapegoat for a small temporary
setback is something playful.
There was a call for a united move from the very same gentleman since
some time past. A section of pensioners also welcomed such an attempt.
Both Sri. H.K.Aggarwal, myself and a few others hoped that combined
efforts and collective wisdom would yield better results. Now it becomes
evident that unanimity may not emerge among the Sr.Counsels. It may
give room for throwing the blame upon someone else, in case of
failures.
I
hasten to withdraw my appeal for a united front. Let us be independent
in our thoughts and actions. Let us be cautious about people who speak
something now and something else later with concocted
explanations.Suffice to be original. Let us not hurt others. God save
them.
With clear conscience,
Yours affectionately,
M.P.Subrahmanian,
RIEA, Madurai.
No comments:
Post a Comment